Bias in hydraulic head measurements from multilevel vibrating-wire piezometers with excessively permeable backfill

An extensive network of multilevel vibrating-wire piezometers (VWP) was recently created to monitor the spatial and temporal variation of pore pressure (and hydraulic head) in the landslide-prone post-glacial marine clay slopes in Québec, Canada. Some of the VWP installations used well-sorted crushed stone as well backfill between bentonite plugs, instead of bentonite pellets or cement-bentonite grout, which could cause a bias in the hydraulic head measurements due to preferential flow within the backfill (i.e., a hydraulic short circuit). This study uses steady-state two-dimensional radial-coordinate numerical models to quantify the extent of this potential bias, and focuses on the relative importance of the following components: hydraulic conductivity of the crushed stone, length of the backfill intervals, length of the bentonite plugs, magnitude and direction of the vertical gradient, and the degree of vertical and horizontal anisotropy within the clay. Simulation results show that the use of crushed stone as backfill results in measurements of hydraulic head that differ from undisturbed conditions by ±0.25 to ±210 cm, regardless of the values assigned to the parameters of interest. In all cases, the cause of this bias is a series of hydraulic short circuits resulting from preferential flow through the crushed stone intervals.