Variation in paralytic shellfish toxin composition within the Protogonyaulax tamaronsis/catenella species complex; red tide dinoflagellates

Unialgal isolates of the Protogonyaulax (-Gonyaulax) tamarensis/catenella species complex, a group of dinoflagellates which causes paralytic shellfish poisoning (PSP), were subjected to toxin analysis by HPLC. Protogonyaulax isolates from widely separated geographical locations were compared, including the northeastern Pacific (British Columbia and Washington State), eastern Canada, Portugal, the United Kingdom and New Zealand. Two distantly related gonyaulacoid species were also analyzed, but the presence of PSP toxins was not detected. Although Protogonyaulax isolates varied markedly in total toxin concentration and toxicity, even through the culture cycle, the toxin ratios of individual isolates were distinctive and relatively constant. No toxins were detected in the Plymouth (U.K.) isolate of P. tamarensis, from the species type locality. Two isolates from Vancouver Island (British Columbia), which were previously considered to be non-toxic according to the mouse bioassay, revealed weak toxin spectra by HPLC. Within populations from English Bay (British Columbia) the toxin profiles of tamarensoid isolates tended to be conservative. However, this was not the case for the catenelloid forms from Washington State, which displayed a greater degree of toxin heterogeneity. Significantly, there was no identifiable relationship between toxicity or toxin profiles and the morphological characteristics conventionally used to separate the two dominant morphotypes into species within this species complex.